New Supreme Court Ruling Tightens the Requirements for Impact Assessments

16.11.2026
Expertise: Energy, Environmental Law Author: Hege Mortensen & Håkon Steimler
test

Greenpeace Nordic, Nature and Youth, and Save the Children have recently won a case before the Norwegian Supreme Court concerning the validity of oil and gas production licences for three areas on the Norwegian continental shelf: Breidablikk, Tyrving, and Ygdrasil, which comprises the Hugin, Munin, and Fulla fields.

The case was heard by a Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court comprising 11 justices. The Court was divided, with six justices forming the majority and five dissenting.
 

The development of these fields is considered Norway’s largest ongoing industrial project, with total investments exceeding NOK 200 billion. Emissions from the oil and gas produced will be equivalent to nine times Norway’s total annual CO₂ emissions.
 

The case concerned the validity of the licences granted by the Ministry of Energy. The operators of the production areas were not parties to the proceedings. The dispute was between the environmental organisations and the Norwegian state. The question was whether procedural errors in the Ministry’s handling of the applications rendered the licences invalid.
 

Which emissions must be assessed?

 

The central question was which emissions companies must address in their environmental impact assessments when applying for a production licence. Must they describe the consequences of the emissions generated when the oil and gas are burned (combustion emissions), or is it sufficient to address emissions from the extraction process itself (extraction emissions)? Combustion emissions occur primarily outside Norway and account for 95% of the total emissions associated with Norwegian oil and gas activities.
 

The Supreme Court majority concluded that the licences granted by the Ministry of Energy were invalid because the companies’ environmental impact assessments covered only extraction emissions. This was insufficient. Gross combustion emissions must be described and assessed in an environmental impact assessment before a licence may be granted. The consideration of applications for production licences is the final stage at which the authorities can assess a discovery’s contribution to global temperature rise and, consequently, its climate impact.
 

The application process therefore provides the last opportunity to assess the climate impact before a licence is granted. The Supreme Court accordingly concluded that an environmental impact assessment addressing only 5% of the total emissions resulting from a production licence is insufficient.
 

The Supreme Court based its position on Norwegian law, EEA law, and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
 

Total emissions must be assessed, but the duty to assess has limits

 

In addition to requiring environmental impact assessments to cover total emissions, the Supreme Court held that assessing each area in isolation is insufficient. Applications for production licences must be considered alongside other production licences granted on the Norwegian continental shelf. The Supreme Court stated:
 

“The effects of the project in question must therefore be considered in light of, and in conjunction with, the fact that the Norwegian authorities have already authorised a number of other petroleum extraction projects that generate substantial combustion emissions.”
 

The environmental organisations argued that the environmental impact assessment also had to show how the emissions would affect Norway’s carbon budgets under the Paris Agreement. They further argued that the assessment had to describe the consequences of the climate change resulting from those emissions. The Supreme Court held that there was no requirement to assess these matters.
 

The authorities must give reasons for their decisions

 

The final main issue concerned the requirements governing the authorities’ review of the environmental impact assessments prepared by companies as part of their applications for production licences.
 

The Supreme Court held that decisions granting production licences must state the reasons on which they are based if the courts are to review them effectively. This means that the Ministry must evaluate the environmental impact assessment and explain how combustion emissions and their contribution to global temperature rise have been taken into account and assessed in the licensing decision. The Supreme Court held that the decision must contain a substantive assessment of the adverse climate impacts resulting from the production licence.
 

Why is the judgment important?
 

This judgment is the latest in a series of decisions in which the Supreme Court has set aside administrative decisions because of inadequate procedures. These judgments demonstrate at least two things:
 

  1. Administrative decisions are not necessarily lawful simply because they have been made at the highest level, in this case by the Ministry of Energy.
  2. The separation of powers works in Norway. One of the courts’ core functions is to scrutinise the actions of public authorities. The judgment confirms that the courts exercise this scrutiny independently of those authorities.
 

Does the judgment halt development?


No. As the operators were not parties to the proceedings, the judgment does not automatically halt the extraction activities already under way in these areas. The Ministry of Energy must require the companies to prepare environmental impact assessments that meet the statutory requirements. The Ministry must then reconsider the applications on the basis of the new, updated assessments.
 

Implications for other administrative decisions

 

The Supreme Court emphasised that deficiencies in an environmental impact assessment do not automatically render an administrative decision invalid. In this case, the deficiencies were sufficiently serious to result in invalidity.
 

Although the judgment concerns oil and gas extraction, it also has implications for Norwegian administrative law more broadly, including decisions under the Planning and Building Act.
 

The judgment provides important guidance on the requirements for the information and assessments that must underpin administrative decisions, and on the potential consequences of procedural deficiencies.
 

Do you need assistance?


Svensson Nøkleby advises both private and public sector clients on administrative law and administrative procedures. We can help assess the scope of assessment requirements, review whether a decision has a sound basis, and address potential errors through administrative appeals or judicial review.

16.11.2026
Expertise: Energy, Environmental Law Author: Hege Mortensen & Håkon Steimler
Newsletter:
If you would like to receive news and invitations from us, you can sign up for our newsletter.